|
MH: What's a
common misconception guitar players make regarding their selection
of tubes?
NSC:
A common misconception would be the often-debated subject of "new
old stock" vs. "new cheap copies". SOVTEK and Electro-Harmonix
tubes are the real thing. Some of our tubes clearly exceed the performance
of tubes made by any factory back in "the good old days".
First of all, if it wasn't for the guitar amp market, very likely
there would be no commercial tubes
manufactured today. For every tube used today in a nonmusical instrument
type product (including HiFi), there are thousands more meant for
nothing but that. And while this business certainly couldn't be
compared to the chip industry, or any other basic element of the
consumer electronics business as a whole, it's still a market of
some importance, at least to the rock & roll
hardware industry. Secondly, there is a sense of nostalgia that
blurs the memory for some, and completely blinds those who aren't
even old enough to remember the "golden age of tubes".
Manufacturers like Telefunken, Mullard, Amperex, RCA, GE, Sylvania,
(sorry if we've left anybody out here...), faced the same difficulties
making their products back then that we at SOVTEK/ELECTRO-HARMONIX
do today. Difficulties such as finding reliable vendors with consistent
materials for making tubes, balancing the cost of development and
manufacture against the price folks are willing to pay and maintaining
a work force with a culture of production committed to making a
good product. We use the best we can get. Our Russian factory, and
our 20 years of experience doing business there have made it possible
to continue, and in some cases improve on designs that had not evolved
in 40 years. For example, the original 6V6 was designed for car
radios and military mobile communications. Its maximum voltage ratings
and dissipation were limited by the compact design of the package.
Rugged from the standpoint of vibration, but 250 maximum plate volts,
14 watts of dissipation, and that's all she wrote. By the time the
first guitar amps using 6V6's appeared, the advantages were considerable
for manufacturers. The tube was cheap, small and relatively insensitive
to the banging around musical instrument amps are generally subjected
to. No one cared about service life, so they cranked up the supply
voltage and ran them in class AB to squeeze out the watts. One large
manufacturer used a 415 volt supply in their popular 6V6 powered
guitar amp. This wasn't unusual at all. Now all these years later
there aren't too many NOS 6V6's left because folks have burned them
all up! The 6V6-EH, made at the SOVTEK/ELECTRO-HARMONIX factory,
is an evolved design with changes
to the geometry and materials to improve the performance and service
life at the high voltages typical
in guitar amps. There's no NOS 6V6 ever made like this. It has great
tone too!
MH: What's the most common question
asked about tubes?
NSC: Probably "why are
tubes still around?" Yeah, it's a good question. Good tubes
in a good tube amp sound better than the alternatives, any of the
alternatives. It's really encouraging, in this day and age of instantly
obsolete technological hoodoo, a large number of the best musicians
still prefer the sound of tubes. Taste matters. Good sound is important.
MH: What's the most important characteristic
about choosing the right tube?
NSC: This will vary with the
individual, but you can narrow it down to a few basic concepts...
Sound, reliability, consistency and flexibility. One of the unavoidable
problems you face is that music isn't a collection of signals or
functions that can simply be engineered, it's a culture, a form
of human expression. All the messy human stuff that goes into anything
like that also goes into what makes one tool better suited for music
over another. We at SOVTEK/ELECTRO-HARMONIX believe that a great
tube will be the one that gets you connected to the flow of the
music and not worrying about the hardware.
MH: Obviously, New Sensor goes to great
lengths to replicate the sound of vintage tubes. How do you accomplish
this?
NSC: Well, it all depends which
tube you're talking about... The 12AX7-EH, for example, is a small
plate, spiral filament construction quite unlike any "classic"
tube made by RCA or Telefunken, but has much lower hum and microphonics
than the old stuff, while matching the high gain. The transfer characteristic
is somewhat more curved than the "original", producing
a different harmonic distortion spectrum. The 12AX7-LPS, on the
other hand, is a true classic "long plate" construction
(this concept only exists because many companies switched to the
"small plate" style because of the guitar amp's special
requirements). A spiral filament is added for improved hum immunity
with AC heaters. The electrical properties have been matched to
the "old-school" 12AX7 specification as much as we can
make it. All of this means a long straight transfer characteristic
with low amounts of odd order
harmonics. The 12AX7-EH has a
little "bump" in the third harmonic near clipping, which
makes it appealing to high gain
overdrive freaks. The 12AX7-LPS is for "classic" sound
in guitar amps or high performance tube HiFi. So, the answer is
that we try to make tubes that fit our markets.
MH: In the day
and age of die hard tube amp lovers, what's your opinion on the
modeling technology used to recreate the sound of real tubes?
NSC: Modeling seems to offer
convenience over sound at this point. Today they don't get that
close to the qualities that make the best tube amps desirable. For
the musician that needs 14 different amps and effects in some particular
circumstance, but for one reason or another (whew!) cannot drag
the equipment around, nothing can compete with a modeling amp! Also,
it
seems to me that most of them just use a little low pass filtering
and some wiggly math in their approximations of tubes and this is
a crass oversimplification of the subtlety and harmonic richness
of the real thing.
MH: In your opinion, what model of
power amp and preamp tubes are your preference?
NSC: We are especially proud
of our 6L6-EH. Any style of guitar playing will benefit from the
power and tone of these tubes. Most manufacturers already buy them
from us for use in their amps, but if you haven't tried them, you
owe yourself a listen. For preamp tubes, the 12AX7-EH is the hot
tube right now. Again, most of the large manufacturers are already
using them, but if you're a Marshall user, switching to this tube
will increase your drive, lower the microphonics and give you an
edge you will love.
MH: Any special
equipment or technology that New Sensor utilizes to manufacture
some of the greatest tubes in the world?
NSC: We've
made a concerted effort in the last two years to improve both analysis
and testing of tubes with the goal of identifying areas of improvement
and implementing changes to the tooling and production methods.
Our engineers in Russia and in New York have worked together to
do this. We have also built a sophisticated computerized automatic
tube tester for grading and matching tubes. We maintain a database
of the testing results in order to better understand how
the yield is holding up, in terms of consistency and also to keep
an eye on the distribution of characteristics. It's a good mix of
the old and the new. Imagine testing vacuum tubes in a computerized
tester!
MH: How important is truly matching
tubes when they are replaced?
NSC: This is obviously still
a controversial subject for some, but we would hope that some common
sense is used when replacing tubes. There is no question that a
good set of matched tubes helps the low end extension of an amp
and reduces hum, distortion and increases the output power slightly.
There are many factors that affect the actual current draw in the
output stage beyond the matching of the tubes in a tester. The best
matched pair of
power tubes in the world will still draw different standing current
in amps using wide tolerance parts in the biasing circuits, in amps
that have a very high screen supply voltage (most amp manufacturers
exceed the maximum rating), or with low quality asymmetrically wound
output transformers (often an important feature of many great guitar
amps). As long as the tubes are within 4 or 5 mA and 500 µMHO
transconductance of each other in YOUR amp, they're matched well
enough to get the benefits. None of the companies that made amps
back in the day ever shipped anything with matched tubes, and no
one ever cared. The old classic stuff is pretty insensitive to tube
selection. However, some of the really high gain, high power amps
made today would probably self-destruct if the tubes were really
mismatched. We match within
+/- half mA and within +/-100 µMHO in our tester. That's two
point matching, and I don't think there are many, if any, tube manufacturers
who do this thoroughly? This is a precision jig with regulated supplies
and 1% parts. Very few real world amps are made this way and frankly
they just don¹t have to be made that way either.
MH: What are the
signs of poor performing tubes?
NSC: There are several different
ways that tubes fail, but generally speaking one should pay attention
to the following: 1) How is the lower register? Does the
amp have punch down low? This is a sign of the peak current dumping
capacity and a great thing in any amp. If the amp sounds thin or
shrill, with no warmth or "chunk" to the sound, the tubes
just aren't swinging enough current and it may be that the tubes
suck. 2) When the amp clips, does it do it smoothly? Are
the harmonics produced nice and "chimey"? Or, do they
sound like the amp is going through a stomp box with a dying battery?
Maybe you like that sound? Otherwise, the tubes probably suck.
3) Are the tubes ringing by themselves, or making other strange
noises that don't have anything to do with whatever it is you are
doing to your guitar or bass?
If yes, chances are that the tubes suck. 4) Does the amp
make sudden changes in volume or tonal content that "fix"
themselves when you stop playing? If this is not due to a malfunction
with the amp, there is almost no doubt at all that the tubes suck.
5) Do the tubes sound good? This is really a messy question
because it involves taste and personal judgment. But, it is the
most important question to answer. If the tubes sound good in your
amp, they are very likely perfect.
MH: How often
do you advise changing tubes, and what maintenance can be done to
make tubes last longer?
NSC: We are tube manufacturers!
You should change them every year or even sooner! The more the better!
No, really, modern amps will need the tubes replaced much more often
than your old classic. Probably within 1 or 2 years. But this depends
on how much the equipment is used and in what way. Keeping the amps
properly maintained and biased will absolutely improve service life.
A good relationship with a responsible tech can help sort this out.
MH: What's the best piece of advice you can
pass along to die hard tube junkies?
NSC: Vacuum tubes are here to
stay. As long as you nuts are making amps and music with tubes,
we plan to be the ones making the best. As Mike Matthews, New Sensor's
owner and big fishing guru says, "ROCK & ROLL!"
|